The Hidden Value of Underperforming Properties: Turning Challenges into OpportunitiesBy John Boyett, Los Angeles, CA

In real estate, it is easy to be drawn to properties that are already performing well. High occupancy, strong rental income, and modern finishes make these assets appealing at first glance. But over my years in Southern California’s multifamily market, I have learned that some of the best opportunities lie in underperforming properties. These properties may have challenges, but with the right strategy and vision, they can be transformed into highly valuable investments.

Recognizing Potential

The first step in unlocking value is recognizing potential. Underperforming properties often have issues that are visible at first glance: outdated units, deferred maintenance, low occupancy, or inefficient management. While these challenges can be intimidating, they also represent opportunities for improvement.

I often tell clients that an underperforming property is like a blank canvas. The structure is already there, but with the right upgrades and operational adjustments, it can be turned into a high-performing asset. The key is to look beyond the surface and assess the property’s fundamentals, such as location, structural integrity, and long-term market demand. If those are solid, the property is likely worth the effort.

Renovations and Upgrades

One of the most effective ways to increase the value of an underperforming property is through renovations and upgrades. Updating kitchens and bathrooms, replacing flooring, modernizing lighting, and improving curb appeal can have an immediate impact on rental income and occupancy rates. Small, thoughtful improvements often yield outsized returns.

Community and amenity upgrades are also critical. Outdoor spaces, fitness areas, shared workspaces, and improved parking or security systems can make a property more attractive to tenants. These changes create a better living experience, which in turn increases retention and allows for higher rents. I have seen properties that were struggling simply because they lacked basic amenities transformed into highly desirable communities with the right investments.

Operational Efficiency

Addressing operational challenges is just as important as physical improvements. Underperforming properties are often under-managed, which leads to high turnover, late rent payments, and tenant dissatisfaction. Implementing better management practices, leveraging property management software, and improving tenant communication can dramatically improve performance.

Operational efficiency also includes cost control. Upgrading systems such as HVAC, water, and lighting can reduce utility expenses, while predictive maintenance prevents expensive repairs down the line. Together, these improvements increase net operating income and enhance the overall investment value.

Understanding Market Dynamics

Another important factor in turning underperforming properties into profitable investments is understanding the local market. Not all improvements will yield the same results in every neighborhood. Knowing what tenants in the area are looking for and what comparable properties are offering helps prioritize upgrades that will have the greatest impact.

For example, in certain Southern California neighborhoods, tenants prioritize modern finishes and tech-friendly units, while in others, outdoor space and security features may be more important. By aligning improvements with market demand, investors can ensure that their efforts result in increased occupancy, higher rents, and long-term value appreciation.

Strategic Partnerships and Financing

Transforming an underperforming property often requires both capital and expertise. Strategic partnerships can provide the necessary resources to take on a challenging asset. Private investors, family offices, and institutional buyers may work together to acquire and reposition a property, sharing the risk and leveraging their combined experience.

Financing strategies are also key. Creative financing solutions, including renovation loans or joint ventures, can make it easier to invest in improvements without over-leveraging. Careful planning ensures that the investment generates strong returns while mitigating financial risk.

The Mindset of Opportunity

Perhaps the most important factor in unlocking the value of underperforming properties is mindset. Challenges should not be viewed as obstacles, but as opportunities to create value where others may not see it. Successful investors are those who approach these properties with vision, patience, and a strategic plan.

I have always believed that the most rewarding deals are often the ones that require effort and creativity. Underperforming properties demand more attention, but they also offer the potential for outsized returns and long-term growth. The work may be harder, but the payoff can be substantial.

Final Thoughts

Turning an underperforming property into a high-performing asset requires a combination of market knowledge, operational expertise, strategic planning, and a willingness to see opportunity where others see risk. Renovations, upgrades, better management, and an understanding of tenant demand all play critical roles in this transformation.

For me, helping clients navigate these opportunities is one of the most rewarding aspects of my work. It is about taking a property that may be overlooked and unlocking its hidden potential. Multifamily investment is not just about buying properties; it is about creating value, improving communities, and generating returns that exceed expectations.

Investors who are willing to embrace challenges, leverage their resources, and approach underperforming properties with a clear strategy often find that these assets become some of their most valuable investments. In Southern California’s multifamily market, hidden value is everywhere. It just takes the right approach to turn challenges into opportunities and build a portfolio that stands the test of time.

Share the Post: